WebPiggy took my $100 and won’t give it back

April 17 2013 by Ellen Roseman

After a bad experience, I’ll never buy a prepaid coupon again. And many people are telling me the same thing.

I paid $100 for $400 worth of meat at a Toronto store called The Butchers. Owner Marlon Pather couldn’t fulfill the orders and closed his doors for redemptions as the deadline loomed last September.

No problem. The deal site, WebPiggy, gave me a credit with no expiry date to use for other items.

But a few months later, my $100 credit is gone. I get an email that says WebPiggy has an alliance with Buytopia to feature its deals.

“Any WebPiggy credits are non-transferable, which means that you may not use them towards purchases on Buytopia, nor are they eligible for cash refunds,” says Trishelle in customer service.

How ethical is that? First, WebPiggy didn’t stand behind a supplier who reneged. Then, it didn’t stand behind its own pledge to customers.

Owner Harold Moore, are you there? Do you have anything to say to all the people you let down? Some spent $500 on coupons they weren’t able to use.

Another coupon site, Dealfind, also caught up in The Butchers fiasco, was acquired by TeamBuy. Owner Ghassan Halazon did talk to CBC Marketplace when asked about its restrictive refund policy in an April 12 show.

Be patient, Halazon said. As we grow, we will give refunds beyond the first few weeks. We will do better.

Who wants to wait? Groupon went public at $20 in November 2011, but its its stock price has dropped to $6.30. Investors are souring on the business.

After being burned, I’m dealing only with companies I trust to give my money back if a deal disappoints. If all of us do that, we can force the marginal players out of business.

33 comments

  1. MrDisco

    Apr 17 2013

    The entire group buy concept has been ruined by these unscrupulous vendors. Consumers should not trust any of them.

  2. Illyria

    Apr 18 2013

    Ellen, Webpiggy and Buytopia are two different companies. Why don’t you ask Walmart if they can compensate you for something you bought from Bed Bath and Beyond?

    No you can’t. That’s because they are two different companies, and transferring credit from one to another does not exist. Common sense.

    Trishelle is not educated in human resources or professional customer service and is simply told what to say by the owner, otherwise she is out of a job and can’t pay her bills.

    The owner is not Harold Moore, Harold organizes finances.

    I am annoyed you wasted your time to post information without knowing anything of what you are talking about. You lost money, so did everyone else that bought off their site.

    You wanna talk about it? Know what you’re talking about and stop making up stories. The only truth is you paid and did not receive a refund.

  3. Angela

    Apr 18 2013

    I’m sorry to say that they have teamed up with Buytopia.ca and are not going to refund anyone’s money (I had almost $200 in credit from the meat fiasco), nor are they going to transfer the credit to Buytopia.

    I’m so frustrated, as I am sure many people are. They should not be allowed to get away with this!

    I attempted to use the credit on my account twice and each time I had to send emails because I could not redeem the vouchers. They apologized and recredited my account.

    So…they wouldn’t give me my money back, they wouldn’t allow me to use the credit on any other deals and now I’ve simply just lost my money.

    I just don’t understand how they can do this and continue operating with Buytopia!

    I really do wish that there would be something that could be done as there’s $200 from me, $100 from you, and many many more hundreds from others.

  4. Jerry

    Apr 18 2013

    I was lucky to be one of the early few that managed to get a credit card refund on my Butchers deal.

    But the whole “fiasco” has really dragged on and now it is like a double insult for the customer.

    Buytopia did the same thing when they acquired another deal site in Vancouver.

    There is more information on this Redflagdeals thread:
    http://forums.redflagdeals.com/buytopia-webpiggy-scam-stay-away-1319892/#post16589556

    Would be great to see you putting some pressure on Buytopia to do the right thing.

    I am sure there are plenty of other customers that don’t know what to do at this point and will give up.

  5. Melissa Grosser, Buytopia

    Apr 18 2013

    Wonderful to speak with you on the phone. When we speak with Web Piggy tomorrow, I will definitely bring this up.

    It is a shame that they are not able to figure out a better customer service strategy on their end to keep their customers happy.

    Here is a comment on this situation directly from Ryan Marien, one of our co-founders:

    When WebPiggy recently stopped offering deals to their customers, they contacted our marketing team at Buytopia to become an affiliate partner of ours so their customers would be able to take advantage of Buytopia’s amazing local deals and National Brand exclusives.

    We proceeded to enter into an advertising agreement with WebPiggy. We did not acquire WebPiggy in any way or form. WebPiggy remains as an independent company that is recommending Buytopia deals to its users, but that is the extent of the relationship.

    Buytopia does not have access to any of WebPiggy’s website information or customer information. Any customers who have questions about their Webpiggy account are encouraged to contact Webpiggy customer service directly.

    We are excited to do our best to offer Webpiggy members the best deals on local restaurants, spas, events, getaways and National Brands such as Porter, MBNA, Staples and more.

    - Ryan Marien, Co-Founder of Buytopia

  6. Gloria

    Apr 18 2013

    I too was one of those scam victims. After negotiating with Webpiggy regarding Marlon’s coupons that I couldn’t use, Webpiggy gave me credit to use and I was told that the credit would not expire – they wouldn’t give me the option of a full refund.

    I am sure that there are many others who aren’t even aware of what has happened to their credit. It is very unfair and unethical.

    If this is a partnership and not a bankruptcy, then Buytopia should honour those credits!

  7. Jonathan

    Apr 18 2013

    I was caught in this and Webpiggy is no longer answering my queries.

    They gave me a credit after the butcher problem happened.
    I went with some of their of deals and they didn’t get processed properly – and most of the time I didn’t get the deal offered.

    So, definitely something is fishy. I think that Groupon and other bigger sites are better run.

  8. Elena

    Apr 18 2013

    I, too, bought a voucher for The Butchers a while back. After going to the store several times and them always being out of stock, or out of anything I wanted, and just being rude in general, I decided to get a refund.

    It was a headache to get a credit on Webpiggy. It took several attempts, but in the end I received my credit.

    I never really found anything I liked on the site after, but did check once in a while. The fact that they started only advertising one deal a week vs. the precious several deals a week did not help.

    In the fall, I found something I wanted and I ordered an argan oil hair set. It stated in the voucher that I would enter my shipping details on the vendor’s site directly after purchase of the voucher and provided a code to be entered on the site.

    I purchased it and there was nowhere on the site to enter my address. I waited a bit, thinking maybe the site was down.

    After a week or two, I emailed Webpiggy advising them that I would like to know how to obtain my hair kit.

    The customer service lady said it had already been sent to the address provided on my credit card.

    I was not impressed as the address on the credit card was my parent’s location and not where I was living currently (I wanted it sent to my work address originally and assumed I could do that, as per the voucher).

    She advised me I would get my delivery in 6-8 weeks. After two months, I I followed up, stating I never received my package. No reply.

    I followed up again, stating I would like a credit as it was gettting ridiculous. They did give me a credit. So I now have over $100 in credit on the site.

    I found a steamer I was going to purchase (just to use up my credit, as I was getting nervous their deals were not being regularly updated). But I decided against it, since I did not really need it.

    So now I find the company is out of business completely. I am very frustrated and angry at how this is even possible.

    I would love to file a joint complaint against this company. Clearly, many people’s experiences were the same as mine, very annoying and deceitful.

  9. MT

    Apr 18 2013

    About 18 months ago, I purchased what seemed to be an awesome deal on Webpiggy. It was $300 for accomodation and flight to Las Vegas.

    At the height of the popularity of the voucher years, everything seemed legit.

    Just recently, I felt it was a good time cash in the coupon. I could not find out any information.

    First I tried calling the furnace company that advertised the deal. They directed me to Odenza, the travel agency, and back to Webpiggy itself.

    I also tried contacting Buytopia with no luck.

    I’m extremely disappointed to have been hyped up about a good deal, only to learn later that it was all a scam.

    I don’t know what kind of company Buytopia could be if they would team up with Webpiggy.

    By the way, the rep that I spoke to for Buytopia dismissed rumours that Webpiggy was out of business.

    But emails I sent to Webpiggy were replied to with messages that they were no longer in business. ???????

  10. Marlene

    Apr 18 2013

    WebPiggy is no longer offering deals, claiming they are now partnering with Buytopia.

    So the business still exists, has partnered with another business, but they’ve just randomly decided they want to keep all the consumers’ credits that are outstanding.

    The credit I was given was for a group deal I purchased and the merchant did not provide the merchandise, even months later.

    By the time I contacted WebPiggy, the money-back guarantee period was over, so they offered, and I accepted, a credit.

    I was told at the time by Harold Moore that the credit would not expire and really had no choice but to accept it or lose my money completely, regardless of the terms.

    It’s not a lot of money ($80) but it’s my money and assuming there are more people in my shoes, WebPiggy could be pocketing a nice chunk of change.

    I guess Buytopia is paying WebPiggy for the referral traffic. Maybe WebPiggy could use that money to reimburse their former clients.

    I’m not sure why Buytopia would want a bunch of angry customers thinking they’re affiliated, but I guess any publicity is still publicity.

  11. PJ

    Apr 18 2013

    We have not received a response as yet. Please advise if we still have a $100 credit with Webpiggy. Thank you.
    PJ

    Sent: Wednesday, April 03, 2013 2:01 PM
    Subject: Confirmation of email receipt Re: re the butcher

    Thank you for your email. We will contact you within 24-48 hours.

    Harold Moore, Director of Accounting, Finance
    http://www.webpiggy.com

    Sent: Tuesday, April 09, 2013 9:37 AM
    Dear Webpiggy Customer,

    We will no longer be featuring daily deals on Webpiggy, as we have closed for business.

    We would like to thank all of our loyal customers for your support.

    Best Regards,

    From PJ:

    In other words, you will not honour the credit owing to me.

    Remove my name from your mailing list, as you are not a reputable company, nor is the company you are teaming up with.

  12. Jennifer

    Apr 18 2013

    I also purchased a deal ($150) for the Butchers through Webpiggy. I also never got the meat and finally received a credit that is no good any more.

    I tried to reverse the charges on my credit card, but since this was 2 years ago, my credit card company is refusing.

    It’s not just a matter of the money – I’m upset that we are not protected from this kind of business as consumers.

    I emailed Webpiggy but received an automatic reply. Their website has been taken down and their phone number disconnected. It’s as though they have simply disappeared.

    I called the Ministry of Consumer Services to file a complaint, and though they are sympathetic, they do not take the case if it is under $500.

    I may be contacting a lawyer to see if a class action lawsuit is possible. I think there are a lot of people in the same boat.

  13. Tracy

    Apr 18 2013

    I am in the same boat as you and countless others.

    I just finished with the BBB after lodging a complaint with them about Webpiggy as of this morning.

    My case manager informed me that Webpiggy is no longer operating and therefore my issue cannot be resolved — case closed.

    She did mention small claims court and the Ministry of Consumer Services. She mentioned that if enough people complained about Webpiggy’s practices on the Ministry’s website, they may be inclined to take action.

    I was left with a $290 credit after The Butchers fiasco, but like you I never found anything to use my credit on.

    I cannot believe that a credit that has no expiry date can suddenly cease to exist.

    When I agreed to the credit, there was nothing called Piggybucks, so I did not agree to their terms of sale.

    I agreed to take a credit simply because they would not refund my money.

    As I mentioned to BBB, if Webpiggy has partnered with Buytopia, it is within their power to purchase with “my credit” a Buytopia credit and at least be honourable with the agreement that my credit has no expiration and I can purchase from Buytopia as I see fit.

    This would be the correct customer service-focused thing to do. There should be better consumer protection for people like us who have purchased online coupons past, present and future.

    I am now looking into my options with small claims court and the Ministry of Consumer Services and might even consider launching a Class Action lawsuit, but will have to see if that avenue is even an option.

  14. Trishelle, Webpiggy

    Apr 18 2013

    Dear Webpiggy Customer,

    We will no longer be featuring daily deals on Webpiggy.

    You will still be able to access your Webpiggy account by going to http://www.webpiggy.com.

    On the splash page, click the link that says Click here to view your old Webpiggy vouchers.

    Per our terms of use, any Webpiggy credits are nontransferable, which means that you may not use them towards purchases on Buytopia, nor are they eligible for cash refunds, as outlined below.

    THE FINE PRINT: “PiggyBucks” are form of credit that WebPiggy may issue to Members from time to time in its sole discretion (“WebPiggy”).

    PiggyBucks may be used by Members as a credit towards future purchases made through WebPiggy.

    PiggyBucks can be obtained in one of two ways:

    (1) as a Member of WebPiggy, WebPiggy will credit your account with 5% on every dollar spent of each purchase made by you in the form of PiggyBucks; the PiggyBucks which will be awarded to you after each purchase made;

    and (2) PiggyBucks may, in the sole discretion of WebPiggy, be credited by WebPiggy to a Member’s account as a full and complete refund for the Purchase Value of a Voucher, which the Member acknowledges and agrees will constitute a full refund of such Purchase Value and such Member will have no further rights under the Voucher for which such Purchase Value was originally paid (“Refund PiggyBucks”).

    Incentive Piggy Bucks expire five years after the date of issuance. Refund PiggyBucks will not expire. PiggyBucks have no monetary value and are not returnable or refundable for cash. Resale of Piggy Bucks is strictly prohibited.

    WebPiggy reserves the right to change the terms and conditions applicable to PiggyBucks or to cancel a Member’s PiggyBucks at any time, at WebPiggy’s election and for any reason, without prior notice.

    However, if this is a customer service inquiry, we will contact you within 24 – 48 hours.

    Thank you,

  15. Tim

    Apr 18 2013

    Thanks Ellen, for the info.

    I don’t really fault Buytopia, but I question what they gain by aligning themselves with a company of such bad name/nature as Webpiggy.

    I’m hoping this teaches all coupon companies a lesson. That when you don’t honour your commitment to your customers, eventually, your business will fail because your customers won’t honour you with their business.

    On that end, I hope Buytopia knows what it’s in for in its alliance with Webpiggy. I will be surprised to see Buytopia still in business 2 years from today.

  16. Yashy Murphy

    Apr 19 2013

    Thanks for shedding some light on this issue. I’ve gone through the same rigmarole as everyone else after the butcher incident and have had many failed attempts at trying to purchase anything afterwards.

    Would love to see Webpiggy owners held accountable for their actions and poor judgment.

  17. Harald

    Apr 19 2013

    The lesson here is TANSTAAFL – There Ain’t No Such Thing As A Free Lunch.

    These group buy / coupon companies have sales forces that aggressively sell to vendors, who don’t realize the real cost of fulfilling these risky deals (especially when they get popular). The coupon buyers take out their wrath on the vendor (or the vendor goes out of business) while the coupon companies pocket the profits.

    The answer is simple – don’t play the game. If you think these deals are too good to be true, they probably are. And don’t complain when you end up losing your money.

  18. karen

    Apr 22 2013

    Looks like honesty and integrity has clear limits in the on- line coupon game. I too was burned by Webpiggy and will never buy from Buytopia due to its unholy alliance with Webpiggy. Buytopia did not do their ‘due diligence’ – or they would not have associated themselves with such a shady outfit. Alternatively- Buytopia is just as shady – either way- I’ll steer clear.

    Trishelle is the ultimate company gal – looks like quoting the small print and reiterating the motto is all she can do – I hope you are paid in Butcher’s coupons for your staunch loyalty.

    It’s unfortunate that one writer has chosen to trash Ellen Roseman when her motives are pure and whose work speaks for itself.

    My mantra with all of this is simple – Karma’s a %#%$^ and their turn will soon come

  19. Steve

    Apr 22 2013

    These people from Webpiggy should be taken out of business. Both Harold and Trishelle are big liars and I hope that their conscience will trouble them till they sort this out ethically.

    There must be some legal means for us to deal with them effectively. I am not sure how they are still able to remain in business after that Butcher’s shop fiasco.

    Does anyone have any suggestions? If Buytopia is truthful in what they are saying about their relationship with Webpiggy, they should disassociate themselves from Webpiggy entirely.

  20. Ken

    Apr 23 2013

    I have a question. Why didn’t you simply go to your credit card company to reverse the charges??

    You have almost 2 years to do this with any card. Or did you simply choose to not use your credits, so you would have something to write about?

    I’ve used webpiggy regularly over the past few years and I can’t believe you found absolutely nothing to buy. I got credit from the butchers deal too and used it towards numerous other meat deals WP ran.

    Did you go to the site on a regular basis, or just check it once in a while?

    This level of complaining over nonsense isn’t newsworthy.

    And a few months after you got your credits they closed, Ellen?? The butcher deal was over 2 years ago. Why would you have only received a credit a few months ago??

    Sensationalizing the story doesn’t benefit anyone.

    Furthermore, the company is closed. Would you expect that if Walmart closed, they would call all their customers with store credit to come in for a cash refund? Hell no. Give your head a shake.

  21. Ellen Roseman

    Apr 23 2013

    Hi Ken, where did you get the idea that you have two years to dispute a charge on a Visa or MasterCard?

    It’s two to three months, depending on the card issuer.

    After doing this complaint handling work, I see many cases of people denied a refund on their credit cards because of time limits.

    In fact, many people burned by the butcher, Marlon Pather, were denied a credit card refund and had to settle for a credit from the coupon site. Now they’re burned again.

    Why check the WebPiggy site every day if told there’s no expiry date?

    I could have received daily emails and did for a while. But they were annoying since they were mostly for spas and hair removal.

    Never again. I think prepaid coupons are a complete waste of time and money. Just did it to get a sense of the frustration that others were telling me about.

    I continue to get many complaints about all the deal sites. Only Groupon answers complaints with speed and genuine regret over problems with chosen merchants.

  22. James

    Apr 23 2013

    Illyria = Ken. Same writing style and reference to Walmart.

  23. Ken

    Apr 25 2013

    Yes James, I must be the only person who has heard of Walmart and for some reason posting with 2 names. Why??

    Ellen, I work for Visa and that’s standard policy with us and Mastercard. Not sure about the rest.

    Why check every day? Well, by that rationale, why go to Walmart to use your credit? Why not get someone to bring the products to your house, when it’s convenient for you to look over? (Kind of like the daily emails that are sent…)

    Wow! You have no one to blame but yourself, with that kind of thinking.

    There you go again, showing your lack of journalistic professionalism and sloppy fact checking. Groupon is probably the worst culprit of them all. If you care to use the highly effective and efficient Google search bar, you would easily find dozens of customer service horror stories. Here’s a quick one. Took about 8 seconds to find:

    http://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/showthread.php?t=3877775

    They may respond, but don’t do anything, but give you store credit (sounds familiar). Not to mention their over 1,000 complaints on the Better Business Bureau (over 800 in the past 12 months). Seems legit.

    Do you think that if and when Groupon closes down, they will “do the right thing” and mail out cheques to everyone with credit. (Is that a better reference for you, James?)

    Perhaps, instead of whining that you lost $100 because you didn’t put any effort into redeeming your credit, you could report on something that could help people? Just a thought.

  24. sas

    Apr 25 2013

    I hope the ministry of consumer services looks into this case.

    To me, Webpiggy took the money but did not deliver the “goods”.

    Lessons learned here: If the deals are too good to be true, they must be bad.

    Wait for the crowd to tell their experience before get your feet wet. Maybe you will save yourself a headache.

    If you can’t resist, how about a small amount, say a $25 coupon instead of $100 or more. Thus, your loss won’t be so painful.

    I never got into these “group coupon” buys, because I have never thought they were good business model.

    You may disagree with me, but I’d rather spend a bit more for peace of mind and vendors’ accountability.

  25. MK

    Apr 25 2013

    What a difference a word makes!

    I wrote to Dealfind (you can’t call them) to say a $39 coupon I bought couldn’t be used. The coupon had no expiry date, but the merchant had gone out of business. I wanted a credit to my Dealfind account.

    I bought the coupon in June 2011, but didn’t use it because I was using coupons with expiry dates first.

    Dealfind wrote back that they would not do anything because the coupon was over a year old.

    They offered me a $5 credit if I bought something over $15 at another website!

    I wrote back that I didn’t know “no expiry” meant one year. They wrote back to say that the matter was now closed (bully tactics in my opinion).

    I had 4 coupons to another place that I bought through DealTicker. I paid $160 in total.

    I called the place to redeem. I bought them in April 2011 and they had no expiry date.

    I was nervous because of my Dealfind experience and thought I had better redeem them right away. I called the place and they seemed to be out of business or renamed.

    Then I called DealTicker at their support line (they have a real person you can talk to or you can email.) The woman checked and confirmed they were on the out-of-business list.

    Immediately, she sent me an email confirming my account had been credited for $160. She was pleasant, courteous and professional.

    There are lots of e-coupon companies. My advice? Use DealTicker. Avoid Dealfind.

    I bought most of my coupons from Dealfind. I’m using them up and unsubscribing. Check out DealTicker instead.

  26. NormaK

    Apr 26 2013

    I’m sorry to read of these unfortunate (understatement) experiences.

    Personally, I’d never used WebPiggy. I’ve purchased only Groupon deals and only twice: one with The Body Shop and one with a local restaurant that we frequent and utilized both immediately.

    My experiences were positive. Buyer beware!!

  27. maazbin

    May 1 2013

    To Melissa Grosser,

    Please provide me with a contact for Harold Moore or anyone at Webpiggy. They are cheats & I’m not going to let them get away with my money.

    They sat on my $100 since the Butchers scam & never gave me a refund or responded to my emails. This is unethical business practice.

    I also have a credit with buytopia & I want to pull my money out, having it refunded quickly.

    I am questioning the credibility of a company that entertains any business activity with Webpiggy, which has scammed money.

    I am looking forward to a response asap.

    Thanks,

    Maazbin

  28. Al

    May 1 2013

    I too was taken by Webpiggy as the numerous others on this site. Perhaps we shold file a complaint with the Better Business Bureau of Ontario. Owner Harold Moore needs to be put on record so that he is that everything he has done is scrutinized to the core.

  29. Jason R

    May 13 2013

    I’m a customer who has also been affected by Webpiggy, Dealfind, Teambuy, Groupon. We are purchasing from companies that rely on work being done by other businesses. They are the middle man and have no control sometimes.

    This industry is horrible with customer service and promises. I have spoken to Harold during the Butchers’ issue. HAROLD is NOT the OWNER! It’s like going to Walmart and yelling at the customer service girl for a product that’s broken. Why would the owner pick up the phones and answer emails? Think about it!

    There are usually multiple owners in companies like this. Be smart and make smart purchases. You win some, you lose some. We don’t want to lose but bad things happen.

  30. WebPiggyVictim#0001989

    May 14 2013

    James Vettese is the person who was answering emails after Harold & Trishelle were apparently terminated by Webpiggy.

    The website URL is also registered under his name. He explained to me that Webpiggy has not gone out of business, but that they have partnered with Buytopia.ca (would bankruptcy have protected them?).

    I was left with close to $300 in piggybucks as a result of the Butchers scam and several other failed deals where the vendors could not deliver what they promised.

    I checked the website several times per week over the past year or two, but the quality of their offerings dropped dramatically (spas teetering on bankruptcy, laser hair removal, botox injections in Scarborough strip malls, crap that the buyers at Winners would turn up their up noses at).

    I purchased several other deals with piggybucks that went sour over this period as well.

    I tried to get a refund from VISA immediately after the Butchers scam came to light, but they refused a refund because I had waited too long (120 days was the limit they gave). Piggybucks was my only option.

    The BBB has a huge list of complaints, but will not take any action (says it’s not their role).

    What can we do to exact some revenge on those who benefited from this debacle and pocketed our cash?

    I am positive that James Vettese and his buddies feel safe in thinking nobody will bother taking this to court over $100-$300. But when you multiply those amounts by the thousands of victims, there may be something to slam them with here. They should not be allowed to get away with this.

    Mr. Vettese has simply moved on to another marketing job and is likely formulating his next scam.

    First step towards getting some justice for our losses, anyone?

  31. jenny t

    May 14 2013

    i am in the same situation. $300 worth of credits due to The Butcher, a few returned Webpiggy vouchers, numerous unanswered phone calls, some unreceived products.

    And now Buytopia is hiding behind the nonexistent Webpiggy’s back. Great going.

    I am an active member in my community and will advise people AGAINST Buytopia. Such a scam.

    Losing their reputation over a few emails of very frustrated customers. Nice business decision.

  32. Julien S

    Nov 7 2013

    Any updates on any of you?

    Before their shutdown, I tried to use up my credit of $200. Either the product never got delivered and i kept getting re-credited, or the product was so much on backorder that they cancelled the request and gave me back credits.

  33. Ray

    Dec 17 2013

    My Vegas trip is not going to happen any more. I contact the BBB, but they can’t do much except take your complaint, log it and follow up.

    My ccard company says the purchase was made beyond the time limit to reverse it.

    So if there is another way to go about getting some kind of justice, let’s all do it.

Leave a comment